Taboo Christmas Read online

  She'd been doing a downward dog. Her pert behind was high in the air. As those skintight Lycra pants stretched over her flawless buttocks, it took everything in my power not to go over and fuck my sister's brains out right then and there. There wasn't a doubt in my mind that she knew the effect she was having on me. As innocent as she pretended to be, she wasn't practicing yoga strictly for the "exercise." She was putting on a very special performance for her older brother.

  I was on the brink of coming for the second time when Paige reached back and pulled me out of her.

  "Whoa, baby, what's wrong?" I said. "I haven't got you off yet." I had been waiting to hear the delicious whimpering noises Paige usually made when she had an orgasm.

  "As fantastic as this feels, Carter, one of us has to be the grown-up this morning. Playtime is over. I can't delay a minute longer; I really need to get ready." She slid the shower door open and gently pushed me out into the cold. "Go wake up your sister. Make sure she's ready to go and waiting at the front door for me."

  "We're not finished here," I insisted. "I can't let you go off to class still feeling horny and unsatisfied. That would make me a terrible boyfriend."

  "I'll keep my motor revving for you all day, I promise." She reached out to give my cock one last stroke. "This little guy is priority number one when I get back."

  "Little? What are you talking about? He's absolutely hu—"

  She closed the door on my retort and began to sing loudly as she lathered shampoo into her hair.

  I couldn't believe I was feeling more sexually frustrated than when I stepped into the bathroom. How was that possible?

  I toweled off and planned to throw on some clothes before I woke Danielle. There was no sense traumatizing my kid sister with my erection. Just my luck, my pokey cock refused to cooperate. I couldn't fit it into my jeans in such an aroused state. "Fuck it," I said, and threw the pants across the bed.

  In the end I pressed my erection flat against my belly and wrapped the towel tight around my waist to keep my cock hidden and at bay. Once the girls had left the apartment I'd take matters into my own hands and jerk some sanity back into myself.

  I was halfway down the hallway when I heard sounds coming from the guest bedroom. I froze in my tracks. Was I imagining things? Could I believe what my ears were hearing?

  "Oh yes, lick it. Lick it just like that. I need you inside me so badly!"

  The voice definitely belonged to Danielle, and she wasn't being shy about what she wanted. My fists clenched tight and I felt my blood boil. She'd disobeyed the number one rule I'd given her when she came to visit me this week. The rule I'd spelled out in no uncertain terms: she wasn't allowed to bring boys back to my apartment. My pretty little sister was a ripe target for horny campus males. That's why I made sure not to introduce her to my fraternity brothers. Sure, I had improper feelings for my sister, but that didn't mean I was any less responsible for preserving her honor.

  From the sound of things, Danielle had not only snuck someone over, but she was "entertaining" just a few feet away from my bedroom. Which asshole had seduced my sister and lured her into bed? I was going to knock the creep into the middle of next week when I got my hands on him.

  "Oh, yes … don't stop. Fuck me! Fuck me harder!"

  I slammed the bedroom door open, ready to unleash my wrath. But I was unprepared for what I saw before me.

  Danielle was in bed, that was true enough. But there was no trace of a boy in her bed. My stepsister was alone. She lay there, stark naked, with her legs spread wide and her face frozen in shock at my sudden appearance. One hand clutched the tiny pink vibrator that protruded halfway out of her hairless pussy. The other hand was slick with her cream as it hovered over her swollen clit.

  The explosiveness of my arrival into the guest bedroom had jarred my towel loose. Before I could do anything, the fabric slipped from my hips and fell to my feet. My twitching cock was unleashed in all its glory for my sister to see.

  Both of us stood motionless for what seemed like an eternity. Our eyes were fixed to each other's crotches. Neither of us dared to move. At long last I found my voice.

  "What the hell is going on in here, Danielle?" I knew the question was redundant. Any fool could see what she was doing.

  The tiny breasts on her chest heaved as she replied. "I'm sorry, Carter. I couldn't help myself. I heard you and Paige in the other room this morning, and it made me feel so…" Her voice trailed off.

  I don't know who was more embarrassed: Danielle or me. I finally got control of my emotions and closed the bedroom door behind me. As I approached my sister I could scarcely believe the words that came out of my mouth. "It's okay, sis. Masturbation is a totally natural thing. You don't need to be ashamed of what you were doing."

  Danielle's eyes never left my cock. There was a ravenous hunger in them that frankly stunned me.

  "I've never seen a cock in real-life," she said, her voice filled with awe. "Can I touch it, Carter?"

  My mouth dropped open. If nothing else my sister was certainly bold. But what surprised me even more was that I continued to walk towards her bed instead of picking up my towel and going back to my room. My legs carried me forward as if they had a will of their own.

  All at once the puzzle-pieces fell into place. The events of the past week played back through my head in a blur. The way Danielle had showed off her ass to me in her tight yoga pants. The way she spent most of her time wandering around in nothing but her underwear. The way she hugged me too tight and too long when she said goodnight. And now, to discover that she'd been listening in while Paige and I fucked. Either the walls in this apartment were too thin, or Paige and I had made love louder than we thought that morning.

  Had Danielle been fantasizing about fucking me all this time? Did we both share a secret love for each other? It didn't seem possible.

  I stopped at the edge of her bed. She looked like a vision of sin with her legs spread wide and the vibrator still buzzing inside her. Her dark brown eyes remained on my cock as if she was hypnotized.

  "Please, Carter?" she asked again. "May I touch it?"

  Once again I was struck by how much Danielle resembled my girlfriend. The only real difference was my sisters breasts. They were much smaller—a handful at the most—but her erect brown nipples were so thick, so long. It was almost as if they were begging to be sucked, to be tasted. My mouth watered at the sight of them.

  "I find it difficult to believe that you've never touched a cock before, Dani."

  She shook her head, adamant. "Never, Carter! I'm a good girl. I don't do that sort of thing with boys. I'm still a virgin."

  "Go ahead, then. Touch it if you want," I heard myself say. What the fuck was wrong with me?

  Before I could come to my senses and stop her, she reached out to grip my shaft. Her fingers were unable to wrap all the way around, but that didn't stop her from slowly pumping me up and down. I shuddered under her caress. The girl may have been a virgin, but she knew exactly what she was doing.

  The low sound of the vibrator continued to buzz inside her pussy. A thin sheen of sweat covered her body. I'd been with enough women to know when they were on the brink of an orgasm, and Danielle was close.

  So very close.

  "It feels so warm," she murmured. "So thick." As the fingers of one hand continued to tug on me, the fingers of the other went to her glistening pussy.

  I couldn't believe my eyes. My sister was going to keep masturbating! The girl must have been racked with a desperate horniness to even attempt such a thing with me—her brother—standing right there. Instead of walking out of the room to let her finish herself off on her own, I decided to assist. Where had my sanity gone?

  I stepped back and got down on my knees at the end of Danielle's bed. She gasped as I grabbed her by the ankles and drew her towards me. My mouth was on her inner thigh in a flash, licking and exploring. I could taste her sweat; I could smell the sweet aroma of her arousal. My kisses moved lower, devouring my
sister's supple flesh, swirling closer and closer to her hot, pink center.

  Danielle's back arched as my lips brushed across her clit. The air was filled with her soft moans as I drew the dripping vibrator from her pussy and replaced it with my mouth.

  "Oh, god, Carter, yes!" she cried.

  Her head thrashed back and forth against the pillows as my tongue flickered across her folds. Every muscle in her tiny body tensed as I reached under to clutch her ass in a possessive grip while I worshiped her pussy. Her hips bucked upwards as she tried to force my tongue deeper inside her.

  "Yes, lick me there, Carter," she gasped. "Don't stop. Please don't stop!"

  Did she think I was crazy? There was no way in hell I was going to stop. The taste of sweet, virginal cunt had left me craving more. Much more. In the back of my mind I knew that everything we were doing was wrong, but I couldn't stop myself. Now that I'd started, I knew I'd never be able to get enough of my sister.

  "Carter, make me come! Please … make me come."

  With her buttocks still squeezed tight in my hands, I lifted her hips, keeping her pussy pressed snug to my mouth. She squirmed and writhed beneath me as my tongue worked its magic. I sucked on the hard bud of her swollen clit and felt the trickle of her arousal turn into a steady flow.

  Danielle's whole body stiffened beneath me. She turned her head into the pillow to muffle her screams as she was claimed by her orgasm. A hot spurt of her nectar filled my mouth and spilled down my chin. I didn't stop sucking. My lips remained glued to her bucking cunt. I felt like rodeo rider atop a wild bull. I held on until the very end, until my sister's shuddering sobs subsided and her shoulders finally relaxed against the mattress.

  I released her, letting her legs splay limply across the sheets on either side of her body. The juices of her orgasm drenched her swollen folds and spilled down her inner thighs. The musky fragrance of her sex hung heavy in the air.

  "Oh, Carter," she panted. "I've never felt that way before. Nothing has ever made me feel so good."

  "You're about to feel something even better," I said unable to contain my lust any longer. I climbed onto the bed and crawled atop her tiny body. Resting on my elbows above her, I lay my cock across her wet pussy. The length of me stretched all the way to her belly button.

  "You're so big!" she exclaimed. "It's never going to fit."

  "Then we'll have to get it nice and wet first to help ease the way, won't we."

  "How will we do that? I don't have any lube."

  "Oh, there's another way, sis," I said, and eased my way up her body until I straddled her shoulders. Resting my balls against her chest, I let the tip of my cock tickle the underside of her chin.

  "What are you doing, Carter?"

  "Suck my cock, Dani," I said in a husky voice. "Suck your brother's big, fat cock. Get it nice and wet."

  "But I've never done this before. I don't know what I'm doing."

  "Just treat it like a big old lollipop. With a mouth as pretty as yours, you'll do just fine."

  I groaned as she took me in both hands and stretched out her tongue to give me an experimental lick.

  "You taste so good, Carter," she said, kissing the underside of my shaft. Pure pleasure coursed through veins. She may have been a novice, but she wasn't afraid to play with her new toy. Her tongue swirled and lapped around my glans. Her fingers, tugged and stroked at my length. Her warm lips covered every inch of me that she could reach.

  "Let's see how much you can take, Dani," I said. "Open wide for your brother." I gripped a fistful of her long hair and held her steady as I guided my cock into her willing mouth.

  Danielle didn't show the slightest hesitation as she let me slide inside. Her tongue felt amazing. The hot wetness was almost enough to make me explode. I had to tighten my buttocks and clench my teeth to keep the rising tide of cum from rushing out of my aching balls. As much as I wanted to fill my sister's luscious mouth with my seed, there was another place I was determined to put my load.

  I wanted Danielle's tight, virginal pussy.

  She gasped in surprise as I pulled my cock free again. A long string of saliva still connected us together. She'd done an admirable job taking me as far as she could. Obviously she was no match for my girlfriend's deep-throating skills, but she was well on her way to greatness if she kept up the practice.

  "What's the matter, Carter? Did I do something wrong?"

  "You did fine, sis. Look how wet you made my cock." I positively glistened in the early morning light that streamed through her the window.

  "I can't believe I swallowed so much of you!"

  There was no time to waste. Paige would be out of her shower at any moment. If I was going to blow my load into my stepsister's snug little pussy I couldn't waste a single second more.

  I flung the pillows and blankets off the bed as I shuffled around to get into position. I lifted Danielle's legs high into the air, letting her calves rest on my shoulders. My slick cock nestled against the lips of her swollen pussy. She didn't utter a word of protest as my cock slid forward into her tight channel.

  Even though she was technically a virgin, she'd long since lost her hymen from playing with herself. I'm sure she had a much bigger dildo back home in her bedroom. I'm sure she had practiced for this moment for god knows how many years. But that didn't mean she was an easy fit, especially not for a cock as big as mine.

  Danielle's gasps filled the air; her voice was a giddy mixture of pleasure and pain as I pushed deeper.

  Fuck she was tight!

  I looked deep into her eyes as I pushed forward, one slow inch at a time. We didn't need words between us. I could see her urging me on, hungry for me to take her all the way.

  Danielle's whole body shuddered, and I let out a satisfied groan as I filled her completely.

  I lowered my face to hers. Her flexible body bent beneath me until her ankles were alongside her ears.

  "This pussy is mine now," I growled. "Do I make myself clear? Mine."

  She bit a corner of her lip and nodded.

  "You don't give it to anyone else. And you don't touch it without my permission." I thrust into her hard, to make sure she understood what I was saying.

  "Yes, Carter," she said in a little girl voice. Her inner walls gripped me tight, as if to seal the promise between us.

  I backed off and began to slowly pump in and out of her. I'd never experienced a pussy that felt so amazing. I could feel my sister's muscles grip me hard, eager to milk every drop out of me.

  Danielle reached up and wrapped her arms around the back of my neck. The look on her face was one of pure ecstasy.

  "Get ready, Dani," I grunted, pumping faster and faster. "I'm gonna come inside this pretty little pussy of yours until you're overflowing."

  My sister's eyes went wide. "No, Carter, wait! I'm not on any birth control. You can't come yet! What if I get pregnant?"

  "We've gone too far already. You can't give me your pussy so willingly and then not expect me to blow my load. Tell me you want my cum, Danielle. I want to hear you beg for it."

  "Carter … wait…"

  "I know you want my cream inside you, sis," I said. "Let me hear you say the words. You've dreamed of this moment for ages, haven't you? You've been craving my cum since you got here. Admit it to yourself. Now just say the words out loud."

  Danielle's brow furrowed as she wrestled with the conflicting emotions in her head. I could tell that part of her wanted to resist, to be a good, responsible girl who practiced safe sex. But there was another part of her as well; one that wanted to submit to me, to be a bad girl who gave in to the pleasure she so desperately wanted. A pleasure she knew only her older brother could give her.

  Beneath her innocent façade, I could see she had the potential for naughtiness. She'd proven it already. No good girl would ever fantasize about her stepbrother and then let him come this far with her.

  Still, she wavered.

  I reached down between our bodies and swirled my thumb across
her clit. Her whole body bucked beneath me as she was claimed by another gut-wrenching orgasm. Her pussy pulsed around me. The sensation was almost too much for me to resist. Oh, fuck, if she kept squeezing me like that I would blow my load for sure. Danielle wouldn't have a say in the matter at all.

  Finally, she said the words I longed to hear her.

  "Come inside me, Carter!" she shrieked. "Fill me with your cum! Make me pregnant!"

  Her hips bucked hard against me. Her fingernails dug deep into the back of my neck. With an animal roar I ejaculated into Dani emptying every last drop of myself into her willing body. Never in my life had I experienced such a satisfying release. My breath came in ragged gaps as Danielle's pussy claimed every ounce of essence from me. Just as I'd promised, her pussy overflowed with my seed. My creamy cum poured from her quivering cunt and spilled thickly across her anus as I withdrew.

  I got to my feet and couldn't believe what I'd done. Sanity returned like a bucket of cold water across my head. I looked down at my sister and pointed a stern finger in her direction.

  "We have to keep this a secret," I said as I tried to catch my breath. "What happened here is between you and me. Do you understand? No one else needs to know." I reached down and picked my towel off the floor. "Get up and get dressed. Paige is going to take your around campus after her study group. She wants you ready and waiting for her by the front door."

  "Please don't go Carter," Danielle said as I wrapped the towel around my waist. "I want you to stay here with me. Come back to bed."

  I clenched my teeth tight. What was wrong with the girl? Didn't she realize we had taken a huge risk by giving in to our taboo desires? My girlfriend would kill us if she caught us together, especially when she saw that Danielle and I were naked and covered in each others' cum.

  "Get up and put your clothes on," I said and stormed into the hallway.

  I hurried to the kitchen to quickly wash my cock and rinse the pussy juice from my face. As I made my way back to my bedroom, I caught sight of Paige leaving Danielle's room. My girlfriend's wet hair was tied back in a loose ponytail. She was dressed in a pair of tight jeans and an equally snug t-shirt. All her assets were on display. There was no denying that she was one hot babe.